Some Comparisons of Abu Ghraib soldiers to other soldiers convicted/plea deals :


CPL Graner                           PVT Brand                            SSG (name withheld)
Charges :
Assault;                                      Assault;                                  Assault
Maltreatment;                              Maltreatment;                         Unlawful Discharge of a Firearm
Conspiracy;                                 False Swearing;                      Robbery
Indecent Act;                               Maiming;                               Dereliction of Duty
Dereliction of Duty

At General Court-Martial; maximum punishment would be :
15 years; DD; E1                        16 years; DD; E1                      24.5 years; DD; E1

Received:
10 years prison                           Reduction in Rank E1                 Letter of Reprimand;
Fine               
DD; E1                                                                        





PVT England                          SFC Perkins                                CPT Martin
Charges:
Conspiracy                                Aggravated Assault                            Aggravated assault
Maltreatment                              Assault cons. By battery                     Assault
Indecent Act                              Obstruction of Justice                        Obstruction of Justice
                                                                                                  Conduct Unbecoming an
                                                                                                  Officer
At General Court-Martial; maximum punishment would be:
10 years; DD; E1                        11.5 years; DD; E1                             9 years; DD

Received:
3 years prison;                            6 mo prison; Reduction                       45 days’ prison;
DD; E1                                      to SSG; Fine                                       Fine





SPC Harman                                SPC Canjar                        SFC Stauffer
Charges:
Conspiracy                                        Maltreatment                            Maltreatment
Maltreatment                                      False Statement                        Obstruction of Justice
Dereliction of Duty                              Dereliction of Duty                   Assault

At General Court-Martial; maximum punishment would be:
5.5 years; DD; E1                                6.5 years; DD; E1                      6.5 years; DD; E1

Received:
6mo prison; BCD;                                 Extra Duty; Fine                        Reduction to SSG;
Reduction to E1;                                   Reduction to E1;                        Letter of Reprimand
                                                    Gen. under honorable
                                                    Conditions Discharge





SGT Davis                                        Lt Pavlik                                SSG McKenzie
Charges:
Assault                                        Violating Lawful Order                  Maltreatment
False Statement                             False Statement                           False Statement
Dereliction of Duty                        Conduct Unbecoming                  Dereliction of Duty
                                             An Officer

At General Court-Martial; maximum punishment would be:
6 years; DD; E1                                7.5 years; DD;                         6.5 years; DD; E1

Received:

6mo prison; BCD;                             1mo prison;                             Extra duty; Fine;
Reduction to E1;                               Dismissal from Army                Reduction to SGT;
                                                                                               Gen. under honorable
                                                                                               Conditions Discharge





SSG Frederick                                SFC Price                                    CPL Berg
Charges:

Assault                                        Maltreatment                                Negligent Homicide
Conspiracy                                  Obstruction of Justice                   Self-Injury
Dereliction of Duty                       Assault                                        False-Swearing
Indecent Act

At General Court-Martial; maximum punishment would be:
10 years prison; DD;                     8 years prison; DD;                      11 years prison;
Reduction to E1;                           Reduction to E1;                           Reduction to E1;

Received:
8 years prison; DD;                       Reduction in rank to                      18mo prison; BCD;
Reduction to E1;                           SSG;                                            Reduction to E1;





SPC Sivits                                        SGT (name withheld)                 SSG Rhoades
Charges:
Conspiracy                                         Aggravated Assault                  Impeding an Investigation
Maltreatment                                       Robbery                                 Maltreatment
Dereliction of Duty                              Dereliction of Duty                                
                                                   Unlawful Discharge of a
                                                   Firearm

At General Court-Martial; maximum punishment would be:
3.5 years prison; DD;                        24.5 years prison; DD;                12.5 years prison; DD;
Reduction to E1;                                Reduction to E1;                        Reduction to E1

Received:
1 year prison; BCD;                           60 days prison;                          30 days prison; BCD;
Reduction to E1                                Reduction in Rank;                                         





SPC Ambuhl                                SGT Boland                                   CPT Cunningham;
                                                                                                   Major Gwinner;
                                                                                                   Lt Col Sassaman;
Charges:
Dereliction of Duty                         Dereliction of Duty                      Conspiracy to impede
                                                                                                a homicide investigation;

At General Court-Martial; maximum punishment would be:
6mo prison; BCD;                           6 mo prison; BCD;                       5 years prison; DD
Reduction to E1                              Reduction to E1;        

Received:
Reduction to E2;                             Letter of Reprimand                      Article 15’s
Other than Honorable
Discharge;